Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Topic: Reading As Conversation: using sources


QD.
1. In the writings by Kantz, she proposes that facts are basically claims that are recognized by society as the 'truth'. Such examples that Kantz uses is the idea of how the earth is round, and states that it is known as a fact, however it can change with opinion as many can consider the earth as a more complex shape and not just "round". Kantz is basically saying that 'fact's are just claims that can change with thought or time. Important books such as textbooks and encyclopedias are known for their factuality in reality according to Kantz, they're just agreed 'claims'. 
Kantz also states that opinions have a way of changing facts in their own way. Ideas are always there, and that affects opinions in every way. Most students are usually taught that an agreed and accepted opinion is somehow a fact. 
But part of the whole delicate system of facts and opinions are the arguments that change the way people think. When there are arguments involved there is self questioning and arguing about what the facts might be. Coming to a point that new ideas with thoughts due to arguments can lead to new agreed claims that turn into known facts. 

2. Kantz is constantly stating that students often forget who their source's audience is. Forgetting that it even though it could be factual, it's a better chance that the writer is pleasing it's targeting audience throughout the book. Students often forget the real meaning of a fact, forgetting that facts are basically society accepted claims. Another misunderstanding is due to the fact that many students growing up accepting facts and turning them into arguments that they forget to question what the facts actually might be. 
Overall the list of things students don't really understand/misunderstand is easily relatable. I think I've personally done all the mistakes Kentz has mentioned. From forgetting the author's audience to even the simple idea that facts are just accepted claims. With all the research and science going on, it's often difficult to forget what a fact really considered to be. 

AE

2. Prior to this class I was taught to really keep creativity and research away from each other. That they were both in different areas and there should be no cross between them. Research was to base the information on hard cold facts, and looking up the correct information. On the other hand creativity was very encouraged in certain classes and banned in others. Take Chemistry for example, there was no way that I could find a 'creative' side to it, yet research in chemistry was looked in such a positive light. On the other hand Kentz thinks that creativity and research should go hand in hand. There should be a creative way to turn research into something you can use in a paper. Our ideas certainly don't overlap, yet I still understand where she's coming from. She thinks that in order to write a good paper with solid research, there needs to be a creative way of blending it in with facts. Her way would be perfect for writing subjects but unfortunately I still believe I can not use 'creativity' in certain topics such as chemistry. 

Meta Moment:


A problem that comes up constantly is the 'writer-based prose' where students usually think that 'factual texts' tell them the truth about the topic instead of the arguments there. 
Another one of the constructs that don't work is the rhetorical reading. It can not be used to create great arguments. 
Kantz is analyzing that they all don't all have positive effects sometimes and students need to use them in the correct way when writing. It would be really useful to understand her claims and findings because it could really improve the way we write our essays , and how we research in the first place. 



No comments:

Post a Comment